Wednesday, September 20, 2006

The Browns need Urban Meyer

It finally occurred to me last night: I know what the Browns need to turn their fortunes around. And they don't have to look any further than Gainesville, Fla.
The Browns need Urban Meyer as their head coach. And that's why, today, I am officially kicking off the "Bring Urban Back to Ohio" campaign.
For those of you scratching your heads, thinking that if the Browns should go after any college coach, it should be Jim Tressel, let me give you a short history lesson.
In 2001, I first met Meyer when he became the coach of my alma mater, Bowling Green. He wasn't a blowhard. He wasn't a cantankerous leatherhead. He was simply good.
I was the sports editor of the student newspaper that fall when I watched the Bowling Green football program undergo an amazing transformation with little fanfare. With quiet, effective steps, Meyer eliminated the sludge left behind by former coach Gary Blackney, who likely stayed around a few years too long, and installed a new, exciting brand of football that he truly believed in.
It wasn't the paint-by-numbers football that Browns coach Romeo Crennel and offensive coordinator Maurice Carthon lean on; it was adventuresome. It embraced the big play. And if the big play didn't work, Meyer didn't abandon it for screen passes. He kept calling for it.
Meyer's offense, kind of a hybrid between a spread and West Coast scheme, turned an undersized quarterback in Josh Harris into an NFL prospect. With it, the Falcons performed the biggest turnaround in college football that year, jumping from 2-9 in 2000 to 8-3 in 2001, including wins over BCS conference teams in Missouri and Northwestern.
In one season, Meyer turned around a stagnant football program with very little roster turnover. His team latched onto his passion, enthusiasm and willingness to stick his neck out.
When Meyer left for Utah after the 2002 season, we might have been disappointed in BG, but we knew this was a coach destined for big things. Sure enough, he led Utah to a BCS bowl game and managed to get starting quarterback Alex Smith picked first overall in the NFL draft.
Then he was on to Florida and the real big-time of college football.
Meyer probably isn't ready to leave Florida just yet. But give him a few years to make the Gators back into a national powerhouse. Then he might be ready for the next challenge. By then, the only place he will not have conquered will be the NFL.
In a sit-down interview with me shortly after he was hired in BG, Meyer said he had no desire to go to the NFL.
"I have had opportunities to go to the NFL, but I love the college game," he said.
That might still be true, but let's wait and see what happens when he's scaled the college mountain and starts thinking about a seven-figure payday in the pros.
Now, I know what you are thinking: college coaches have a long history of falling flat on their faces in the NFL. The mentality is much different. NFL coaches are dealing not with wide-eyed kids but with grizzled veterans made callous to authority by million-dollar paychecks and years in the game. They can't just step in and demand respect. It has to be earned.
But Meyer, I think, doesn't view himself as a cure-all football guru the way Steve Spurrier and Butch Davis did upon arriving in the NFL. What Meyer would need is a general manager savvy and knowedgeable about the ways and means of the NFL. A GM who knows the salary cap, free agency, the draft, contract negotiations and above all, has a talent eye similar to that of Meyer.
The GM would need to be good enough to let Meyer do what Meyer does best: be an inventive, creative coach.
The Browns have the personnel to fit a Meyer system. Braylon Edwards is a playmaker. Kellen Winslow Jr. is a tough possession receiver who specializes in yards after the catch. Dennis Northcutt is a deep threat. Joe Jurevicius is a middle-route possession receiver.
Charlie Frye is a mobile quarterback, kind of a bigger, more athletic version of Harris and Smith. Reuben Droughns and Jerome Harrison could give Meyer all types of different looks out of the backfield.
I don't think it would take long for Meyer to put the right pieces in the right places, at least on offense.
Meyer is an Ashtabula native who played football at the University of Cincinnati. He knows what a rabid football area this is. Passionate fans are something he demands when he takes over a football program.
When the time is right, the Browns would provide a suitable project for him.
He is one of the few coaches who I think could return exciting football to the shores of Lake Erie.


Joel said...

Whatever you're smoking, I'll have some of it.

What the Browns don't need is a 40-year-old coach (isn't he around 40?) to come in and try to be a disciplinarian. That's the LAST thing Kellen Winslow needs. Charlie Frye, maybe. Reuben Droughns? Nuh uh.

I remember another Florida coach who was a big-time stickler for details, an offensive genius.

His name's Steve Spurrier. He lasted two years in Washington, and now coaches South Carolina, who couldn't score with Paris Hilton.

If Meyer were smart, he'd ignore this column.

Erik said...

You should be glad I cut the column at Urban Meyer. I was thinking about saying that once Meyer arrives, he should cut Charlie Frye and make Josh Cribbs the QB.

And I think Meyer is ignoring this column, loud and clear to be sure. But I think it's still fun to brainstorm.

Mark said...

I certainly don't think that Meyer is ready for the NFL yet, and so I agree with you there.

I think it unrealistic to outright say that college coaches do not have success in the NFL. Sure, Nick Saban is off to a rough start in Miami this year, and Butch Davis and Steve Spurrier fizzled out, but let's look at the past here.

Butch DID give the Browns a playoff team and a one-year turnaround that no one could have dreamt of. Look back farther now: Bill Walsh, Jimmy Johnson, and Barry Switzer all coached college ball and won Super Bowls.

Given this past precedent, you are right on the money to emphasize that it's not so much the coach as it is the TEAM. Put together a team of dynamos and I, having no football experience whatsoever, could win a championship with them, so long as I can motivate them and make them believe in my system (what system?). College coaches have those motivational tools.

Sure, these days they might get disillusioned a lot quicker with the high salaries and lack of respect, but you could also make the argument that the pieces simply were not in place for some of those fizzles. So why not Urban Meyer and a savvy GM? Good question.

BDoc said...

Being a UF alum, and a fan of all things Gator, I was very excited when Meyer announced his decision to coach at Florida.

I could see him trying the NFL some day, if only for the sake of finding out exactly what he could accomplish. He's able to tailor his gameplan to fit the personnel he has, and he seems to motivate without incurring anger or resentment.

Personally, I hope that Crennel works out for the Browns, though that might be because I hope Meyer stays, and succeeds, at Florida for many years to come.

John said...

Cause the Browns need another college coach.

Anonymous said...

I don't diagree with you that Urban is a hell of a coach. But I'm curious how well his "system" would work in the NFL.

The fact that he turned around college team's with little player turnover shows me that he was simply outcoaching his opponent. They couldn't counter his innovative offenses. That is very unlikely to happen in the NFL, with the Grudens and Sabans of the world pouring over game film for 25 hours a day. You really can't "coach 'em up" at the highest level.

Plus, how often do those "spread" type of offenses really succeed at the NFL level? Urban's UF predecessor's Spurrier - failed because he couldn't protect his QB, which was easier to do in college. Those types of offenses just don't produce results (Super Bowls) in the NFL. The Rams with Marshall Faulk and Kurt Warner are the only one that comes to mind - and that offense worked primarly because it centered around the most versatile running back of a generation (not working so well with Kevin Jones and Jon Kitna, is it, Mr. Martz?).

No, the formula to succeed in the NFL these days, I think, is balance. A stingy defense and a balanced, capable offense. Look at th latest Super Bowl winners: Steelers, Patriots, Bucaneers, Ravens...all had better defenses that offenses. Just ask Peyton Manning and the Colts. You just can't "out-system" someone in the NFL.

Uncle Rico said...

I think Meyer should worry about succeeding at a major D1 program first. He hasn't yet.

Further, success at Bowling Green & Utah doesn't guarantee success in the NFL.

Step away from your crack pipe!